A Plea to Moderate Christian Leaders and Pastors
I’m sure many of you are losing sleep trying discern how to navigate these unprecedented times in our country. Our President has ushered in a level of public rhetoric that is vitriolic and hateful. Any argument for moral leadership has been lost and the cascading impact of his words are catalyzing a frenzy of support leading to public chants that are antithetical to the gospel (not to mention the values of the United States). History tells us that this kind of language normalized by those representing a diverse population leads to destructive ends…especially to minorities and the most vulnerable.
And, in the midst of it all, you may have elder boards, congregants and donors who are likely more committed to partisan fidelity than fidelity to the Kingdom inaugurated and embodied in Jesus. The stakes are high. Which is why how we lead in this moment is so critical…not to our partisan politics, but our collective witness as the Church.
I’ve met, led alongside and taught in your pulpits and lecture halls for most of my adult life. You’ve resonated with and celebrated a message I often share about the need to disciple our communities toward an unwavering allegiance to the Kingdom of God (and it’s values) above and beyond any kind of allegiance to our nation-state. And also to take seriously our responsibility to leverage our citizenship in the United States on behalf of those on the underside of power. We must embrace a conflicted allegiance.
It’s one thing to agree with this message, it’s a whole other to live into it with our actions and words.
What is our invitation in this moment?
I’m not inviting you to be partisan, but I am inviting you to be political. The Greek word “polis” can simply be defined as “the ordering of society.” Jesus was NOT partisan, but everything about his teachings, life, death and resurrection was political. It was about ordering society in light of the Kingdom of God. A kingdom where the first will be last and the last first. Where there are no longer lines of exclusion based on religiosity. Where one’s hope isn’t found in the empire/nation-state, but in the resurrected Jesus. Our country is becoming increasing dis-ordered and we can’t collectively stick our heads in the sand to appease elder boards, donors or family members.
The term “Christian” in the United States has been compromised by pseudo leaders hungry for power propagating a campaign of fear. We need to stop inviting our congregants to be this kind of “Christian” and invite them to follow Jesus.
What does that look like?
- An uncompromised allegiance to the kingdom of God. Not a partisan politic.
- Lives that reflect the Fruit of the Spirit (love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self control)
Few things can intoxicate and inoculate Christians like partisan politics driven by fear and a hunger for power. It’s time to disciple our communities in the way of Jesus over and beyond the ways they are discipled nightly by Fox News and MSNBC. It’s time to give your community footholds for navigating this complex and costly moment. It’s time we liberate our collective energies for the work of seeking justice, caring for the vulnerable, walking humbling before God (and neighbor) and participating in God’s mission of restoration.
While this is a critical moment of retaining our faithful witness in the face of hatred, it is not unique to the history of the Church. Whether the early church in Rome, the radical reformers of the 16th century, the church in Nazi Germany (think Bonhoeffer) or the church standing against racism with Dr. King in the civil rights era, we have worthy shoulders to stand on as tangible guides.
With the prophets of old, we pray, “Wake up, O Sleeper!” “Rise up! Rise up!” (Isaiah 51/52)
You are leaders. We are in it together. It’s time we lead as part of an alternative economy. An economy outlined on a hill overlooking the Sea of Galilee and embodied on a cross at the hands of a compromised, nationalistic religion.
This isn’t the end. In fact, it’s likely just the beginning. We can’t be silent. We can’t be held captive to success metrics of attendance and funding. May we have the hard conversations with those of influence. May we stand with our neighbors on the receiving end of the rhetoric. May we create environments where dissent isn’t demonized, but learned from and listened to. May we leverage the influence we’ve been given for the benefit of the vulnerable. May we transcend the toxic binaries of “left” and “right.” May we follow the Jesus we talk about and invite our communities to do the same.
We don’t need to all agree on every policy, but I pray we can agree on our shared hope and give everything we’ve got to make it real in our conflicted world.
Your voice matters. Your actions matter. Your leadership matters.
Let’s get to it together.
Getting Personal: From DOING to BEING
I’ve been taking some really tangible steps in my own personal journey toward becoming a Human-BEING rather than a Human-DOING. For me, and how I’ve been created (and conditioned), doing less and being more is really, REALLY hard.
It’s easy for me to default to task lists and self-imposed to-do’s. At its best, it’s a function of deep conviction and meaningful contribution. At its worst, it’s a function of deep brokenness and misplaced identity.
It’s much harder for me to choose to simply be present to what’s right in front of me. To sit on the floor and play with my kiddos without thinking about work, checking my phone or seeing them as a chore. To sit in silence and stillness for a few minutes before opening my computer to tackle the to-do’s. To say NO to stuff that is really good, but not mine to do. To have the margin in my life that allows for “holy interruptions” rather than “annoying distractions.”
Last week, I said no to an opportunity I can’t fathom saying no to 10 years ago (or even 5 years ago!). An opportunity I could have only dreamed of back then. It was hard. It took discernment. It took listening to really honest feedback from my closest community. It took swallowing my pride and listening to the Spirit. It took a new kind of trust that the most important work I can do is not fixing the world “out there,” but deep diving into the beauty and brokenness in me.
Today, I sit in our local coffee shop with a big, goofy smile on my face. And for no other reason than I’m grateful to be alive. I’m grateful for the random friends who walk through these doors…who over many years have become my “office-mates.” I’m grateful to have the opportunity to work at a reasonable pace rather than an impossible one. I’m grateful my shoulders are less tense and my mind at ease.
Moving from DOING to BEING will be a life long journey for me, but the more I’m stumble toward it, the more the goodness of life turns 3D. A goodness that has always been here, but I often haven’t had the eyes (or time) to see. There is color, joy, pain, tears and hope.
That’s some pretty personal stuff, friends. But, maybe, some of you can relate and find hope in this journey too. Or not. Either way, it’s mine and I’m grateful to be on it.
When the Bible Gets in the Way of Following Jesus
My last post on the Migrant Caravan really struck a cord. As the story continues to unfold, I’m going to pose a challenging theological question with really tangible implications for how we show up in this moment (specifically related to the migrant caravan).
1. The Context
The migrant caravan is made up primarily of people with deep Christian convictions and tradition. As they move north, they are holding vigil, praying for God’s guidance, protection and ultimate liberation. Momma’s are pushing strollers as they pray for their children’s future and pleading with God to deliver them toward safety and new life.
Here in the US, many people with deep Christian convictions and tradition are praying for the migrant caravan to turn around (at best) or violently resisted/restrained (at worst). Parents are fearful that this caravan could threaten the safety and future of their children and are pleading with God to protect them from the “invading enemy.”
2. The Question
How and where does God act in a moment like this? Whose prayers are “heard”? I trust that all the concerns raised by both groups are real to them (although, in some cases, I’d disagree on their objective reality). All are praying with ferver for God to “show up.” One group for safety. Another for liberation.
3. The Reflection
I’m convinced one of the greatest obstacles to following Jesus in the United States is HOW we read the Bible. Namely, how we often read ourselves (specifically dominant culture USAmericans) into the story as the “favored protagonist” who has a corner on the market of God’s blessing.
Some thoughts…
The Bible is the story of an occupied and oppressed people trusting that God will guide them toward liberation. The main characters who modeled faithfulness most often were those OUTSIDE of power. Many of us have been taught (albeit subconsciously) to read ourselves into the biblical story as the protagonist when in reality – whether we like it or not – we have more in common with the antagonist. We live in one of the most powerful and wealthy countries in human history. We don’t need to be ashamed of that, but we do need to be honest about it. And, if we are honest, we have more in common with Pharaoh than with Moses. With Pilot than with Jesus. With those on the side of Empire extinguishing the good news of the Kingdom. As my friend Tony Campolo says, “We may live in the best Babylon in the world, but it’s still Babylon.”
We mis-read the Story when we use the Bible as a tool to support our retaining and maintaining of power when the reality is that it is a Story of God working among oppressed people to distrupt and dismantle oppressive power. We mis-read the Story when we read the text to justify and support systems that maintain the status quo (comfort, power and privilege) when the reality is that the Bible is the Story of God subverting power (economic, political, racial, patriarchal, social, etc). God didn’t give up on those in power, but DID require they repent of their addiction to it and seek their own liberation.
Tangibly, this incomplete reading allows us to interpret our world as though God is with “us” and “they” are the ones who are coming as a threat (in this case, migrants, refugees or asylum seekers), when in reality it was among those communities where God was seeking to deliver all of us in bondage to systems and structures that oppress. Maybe those in the migrant caravan are coming to deliver us back to God in the way Moses delivered Egypt (although painfully) from their addiction to power, safety and comfort. Maybe we are being delivered from our addiction to safety that frees us to be faithful. Maybe we are being delivered from a mentality of scarcity to a celebration of abundance.
Jesus message was good news to those on the underside of power. The captives, the oppressed, the hurting, the diseased. It wasn’t good news for the systems and structures that oppressed them. But it was good news to the oppressor. It was liberating for EVERYONE if only they had eyes to see and ears to hear.
For many of us, it’s going to take a long, confessional journey to read the Bible through the lens of its orginal context and community, but it is a journey worth taking. It will require people like me to listen, learn and be mentored by people around the world (and on our streets) who are faithfully following God on the underside of empire. Our sisters and brothers who aren’t in the halls of power, politics and religious beaurocracy. Those who have been beaten down, displaced and enslaved. We are being invited to new life. To have our sight healed and our wounds repaired so we stop spreading our disease and start spreading the good news.
If this requires a confession booth, I’ll be the first in line.
A Few Thoughts on the Migrant Caravan
-
My heart is heavy and saddened as I watch so many compassionate people talk about this group of human beings in such dehumanizing ways. I understand the fear. Of course we need to protect our children. I get that we have limited resources. Yes, migrants have to enter the country legally. I just don’t think these concerns are near as connected to this migrant caravan as they are to our collective enslavement to fear and misinformation. Rather than be moved by a commitment to understand and care for the “least and the last” we are being stirred into a frenzy of self-protection that is compromising our collective soul. It’s sad. But we can be healed.
-
Many of you may remember the last Migrant Caravan that got alot of news a couple years ago. I was there in Tijuana to welcome them when they stepped off the bus. Who did I meet? Exhausted and scared grandma’s, momma’s, daddy’s, babies and young kids traveling alone holding out a sliver of hope that they might have a future worth living for. This wasn’t a community of people that WANTED to flee their countries…they had no choice. No one would want to go on the journey they are on. Months of jumping on buses, trains, walking with kids on their back, corrupt police and gangs exploiting their vulnerability. 80% of women who go on this journey are sexually exploited in some way. As to this caravan, if women know they can travel with the protection of a group, of course, they are going to do that. THEY ARE NOT COMING TO TAKE AWAY THE AMERICAN DREAM. They are simply trying to have a chance at life.
-
Some might say, “But they should come legally!” Yes, they should. And they are. They are coming to our southern border to walk through the port of entry and seek asylum. That is NOT ILLEGAL, but a central function to the core values of the United States. Now, there are always some who are so desperate (and often misguided by organized crime) that they try to cross the border illegally. Whether some in this caravan choose to do that, I have no idea, but having sat with migrants considering an illegal crossing, I can assure you it is not something they want to do…it is pure desperation.
-
If we are going to engage with this crisis with any kind of integrity and humanity (not to mention faith convictions that require us to care for the foreigner/stranger), we have to ask WHY they are migrating in the first place. What is it they are running from? What could be so bad that they are literally having to choose which children to take and which to leave behind? I’ve talked to mothers of multiple children who had to flee violence in Central American and were forced to CHOOSE which kids could actually make the journey and which couldn’t. They knew this was their ONLY chance of survival and hoped to one day send for the ones they had to leave behind. The level of despair and heartbreak in their eyes is indescribable. A simple study of the history of Central America will not only give us hints as to what these people are fleeing, it will point a finger back at ourselves as participants in the destabilization of the region back in the 1980’s. Violence and economic desperation don’t come out of nothing. We have to become students who ask the story behind the story behind the story. The fact that our administration is threatening these countries by taking away funding is short sighted and will only perpetuate the instability.
-
No number of talking points will change our hearts and minds. We have to get close to those in crisis. We need to be in proximity. We need to share tables and stories. And, in a country filled with immigrants, we can. We just have to choose love over fear and curiosity over critique. Let’s allow relationship to lead the way and the Spirit to guide our steps. For those of us who follow Jesus, let’s remember that he didn’t call us to be safe, he called us to be faithful. Now is our time.